Last Christmas Jenna received a mysterious gift from a Secret Santa who never came forward. Fast forward next Christmas and the mysterious person returns. With more lavish gifts and mysterious messages. When Jenna develops a fragile relationship with her neighbor's son she believes she might have what she's always wanted, love and hope for a real family. Yet, the gifts don't stop. Expensive gifts turn to threatening messages and dead animals in her yard. Everyone Jenna knows is a suspect and soon her loved ones are in danger especially the man she comes to love.